
Title: “Pilot”
Written By: Elizabeth Meriwether
Air Date: Sept 20th 2011 (available now on iTunes)
Jess, a cute but nerdy girl, is cheated on by her boyfriend, and unable to stay with her best friend, she moves in with three guys she found on Craigs List.
Lets get the obvious out of the way, the draw of New Girl is clearly Zooey Deschanel. It’s her first real effort at TV and cos I’m a big fan of this manic pixie dream girl, I’m gonna like this show. It’s inevitable.
The pilot plays to the charm of Deschanel, namely her overwhelming adorability, but I did find the three roommates to be fairly decent too. Nick (played by Jake M Johnson) comes across as a slightly less schlubby Charlie Day. Although the fact that Nick’s ex-girlfriend is played by the waitress from It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia probably helped this comparison.
Schmidt (played by Max Greenfield, probably most known for his role as a sheriff’s officer in Veronica Mars) really is a douchebag, but I feel as time goes by the writers will develop him into a more three dimensional character.
Coach (played by Damon Wayans Jr) is easily the best of the supporting characters so it’s a shame that his other show got picked up for another season and he won’t be continuing on in New Girl. He’s a funny guy that has a nice way of delivering lines. Plus I always think of his performance in The Other Guys and it makes me smile.
So Deschanel is awesome, and the three guys are at least passable, what about the hot model friend of Jess played by Hannah Simone? Well, she doesn’t do much in the pilot except be hot, kinda aloof, and dress Jess in a sexy black outfit. If she continues to just be the hot unfunny friend then I can’t see that she adds anything to the show, but I have a feeling that she’ll end up being a love interest for either Coach or Schmidt.
The one other thing which struck me was the terrible theme song, it sounded like a 30 Rock/SNL sketch joke. It was only after I was about half way through the episode that I realised the theme was a joke based on Jess’ habit of singing about random stuff, and she does in fact make up a theme song for herself. Still, I kinda hope they change the theme song or just do away with it entirely.
Rating: 6/10
Conclusion
It’s a single camera, non laugh track sitcom, so right away it’s better than Two and a Half Men and The Big Bang Theory. I was looking forward to watching New Girl because I’m such a big fan of Zooey Deschanel, but to be honest I wasn’t expecting it to be particularly impressive. For the most part New Girl isn’t that impressive, but it did exceed my expectations, and I really have to credit the extraordinarily lovable Zooey Deschanel for that. I’d like to have a full season of the show to see how they develop the supporting characters, but considering the show airs on the fickle and notoriously demanding Fox, I’m expecting that it’ll be cancelled within the first 8 episodes.